Title Image

Don Xml's Grok This

The home of Don Demsak
Welcome to Don Xml's Grok This Sign in | Help
in Search

This Blog

Syndication

Site Sponsors

DonXml's All Things Techie

Microsoft Codename Acrylic Does Not Do It For Me

First off, I really, really wanted to love Microsoft’s latest graphics tool, codename Acrylic.  I down loaded and install the first public beta, and wasn’t impressed, but hey, it’s an early view into what they are doing, so I decided to cut them some slack (it is based on Creature House Expression, which MSFT bought in 2003).  I recently installed the latest tech preview (Aug. 2005), and I’m really having a hard time working with it.  Now, Forest Key (a Product Manager) has mentioned that "Acrylic is not Expression Studio verbatim There may be some relationship between Expression Studio and Acrylic, but it's not one and the same.", which is a good thing, since I had envisioned a more Visual Studio like development environment, than the floating windows style of Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop.  As a .Net developer who has worked with Adobe to improve Illustrator’s SVG capabilities, from the point of view of a vector graphics artist I've got to say, I hate Acrylic.  There was a long period of time that I wished that I could merge Illustrator with Photoshop, so that I could create vector and raster graphics in one tool, but over the last year I’ve started to see the error in that line of thinking.  Both styles of graphic development take different mind sets, and putting it all in one UI makes it hard to distinguish between the 2 styles.  I’m not saying that it can not be done, it just will not be easy, and the current Acrylic UI doesn’t help.  If MSFT wants to lure the Illustrator or Photoshop artists (and those are 2 different talent pools) to use a tool to create XAML based on Windows Presentation Foundation (formerly codenamed Avalon), they are going to have to do better than Acrylic and make it easier for them to transition their knowledge to WPF.  I know that may mean dropping my VS.Net style UI, but it would be worth it. 

One of the things I noticed with the Aug. CTP is that can't import or export from Illustrator, which was listed as something that could be done in the previous beta release, but didn’t work when I tried it (and I reported it as a bug).  Thankfully, Michael Swanson created a plugin for Illustrator that will export XAML, so that I can continue using Illustrator, and still be able to generate XAML based WPF.

Published Monday, August 22, 2005 8:39 PM by donxml

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

Dave said:

I agree totally with this Don, I was a huge user of Denebas Canvas right up to the point they introduced raster operations (photoediting etc), then I switched to using both Illustrator/Freehand and Photoshop.

They are two separate mindsets and they have to be kept separate and merged at the right time and for the right reason.

Dave .........
August 24, 2005 10:49 AM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

About donxml

I’m an independent consultant, specializing in .Net solutions architecture, based out of New Jersey who also doubles as an evangelist for XML, Domain Driven Design, enterprise architecture and .Net. I do not work for Microsoft, the W3C or any other big company that you may know of (at least not yet). I’ve been an indie for over ten years, and although I’ve been tempted a couple times to take a job with companies like Microsoft, I’ve haven’t found something better than my current situation. I work mostly with the large pharmaceuticals that are based here in New Jersey, and usually find myself on long term contracts. Definitely not the prototypical indie consultant, but it lets me dedicate time to my non-income generating activities like the developer community stuff, plus financing open source projects like XPathmania and MVP-XML. If you would like to talk to me about doing some contract work, just contact me via the contact page. My rates vary widely, depending on lots of different variables, but mostly distance from Jersey, and type of work. Plus, I’ve been known to donate some of my code for various projects.
Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems